The FPI Puzzle: Why 5 and 4 Oklahoma Ranks Above 10 and 0 UCLA
If you thought the College Football Playoff rankings were a mess, wait until you get a look at ESPN Football Power Index, which ranks a 5 and 4 Oklahoma team above a 10 and 0 UCLA team, and rates Ohio State, at 7 and 3, among the best teams in the country.
The FPI is a computer ranking, not the committee ranking, but the gap has become the talking point of the college football season. It raises a question that goes to the heart of the sport: should a team be judged by who it has beaten, or by whether it has beaten everyone it has played?
What the computers see
The FPI loves Ohio State and LSU, and it rates Utah, at 10 and 0, below several teams with worse records. The logic is strength of schedule: the computers believe that Oklahoma, which has played a brutal slate of ranked opponents, would beat UCLA on a neutral field, even though the Bruins have won every game they have played.
Oklahoma case is straightforward. The Sooners have won back to back games over teams ranked by the playoff committee, including a 24 to 17 win over Ole Miss on Sunday, and they also hold a win over Texas. UCLA case is equally straightforward: the Bruins are 10 and 0, and no one has beaten them.
What the committee will do
The playoff committee, which releases its third rankings on Tuesday, November 17, at 9pm Eastern, is not bound by the FPI, and it has traditionally rewarded winning. But the committee also values strength of schedule, and it will have to decide how much to punish UCLA for a slate that the computers say is weak.
The answer will shape the playoff race. If UCLA is ranked highly, the Bruins control their own destiny. If they are ranked low, they will need help from other results to reach the 12 team field, and the debate about whether winning every game is enough will run for the rest of the season.

