Latest Trending
Last Updated, Mar 17, 2026, 7:07 PM
Krause: Don’t light off the Roman candle just yet


In a couple of weeks, baseball will begin anew, and one of the annual guarantees, at least where the Red Sox are concerned, is the emergence of a phenom.

Every team has phenoms, but the Red Sox seem to have more than the other three Boston franchises. They also have more phenoms that don’t pan out.

And that’s a problem, particularly among the front office that has a tendency to read the organizational propaganda and believe every word of it.

Then, of course, they trade said phenom at the first opportunity and watch him flourish somewhere else.

I speak immediately of Roman Anthony, a good-looking lefty who has “Fred Lynn” written all over him. For those who may be a little too young, Lynn came up during the tail-end of the 1974 season and took the league by storm.

Lynn and Jim Rice carried that dominance over to the ’75 season and led the Red Sox to a pennant and one of the most dramatic World Series of all time.

A few more breaks and a few less injuries, and Lynn could be in the Hall of Fame.

Anthony was a midseason call-up last summer, just about at the same time Rafael Devers was unceremoniously traded to the San Francisco Giants. General Manager Craig Breslow said, at the time, that the Devers trade would make the team better, presumably because getting rid of the “malcontent” would lessen distractions.

The Red Sox went on a tear that included a 10-game winning streak right after the trade. But it wasn’t because of the Devers trade or any of the future Hall of Famers they got in the deal. It was because they finally pulled the trigger and brought Anthony up to the club. He terrorized pitchers to the point where he was runner-up as Rookie of the Year.

Why did they wait so long? Why did they promote other rookies who didn’t measure up to Anthony? It may be one of the great Red Sox miscalculations, right up there with trading Jeff Bagwell for a rent-a-lefty-reliever named Larry Andersen.

But Anthony only really played two months before hurting his oblique muscle and missing September, as well as the playoffs. Two months is not really a significant sample.

The whole situation reminds me of Phil Plantier’s time with the Red Sox. Plantier could rake. He might have looked odd up at the plate (his manager, Joe Morgan, said he had a “toilet seat stance”), but when he got his power behind a pitch, the ball went a long way. He also hit .331 and was called “a young Yaz (Carl Yastrzemski).”

As the Red Sox put on a second-half push to vie for the American League East title (unsuccessful), Plantier caught fire. He was the team phenom that season.

During the winter, the Red Sox counted on him to be just as prodigious in 1992, but, of course, he wasn’t. The glass slipper fell off.

By the next season, Plantier was banished to the San Diego Padres for José Meléndez, who made such an impression on me I don’t even remember him. Plantier, meanwhile, had his best season, hitting 34 homers with 100 RBI. For the Padres . . .

Some of our phenoms have had tremendous success. Tony Conigliaro was touted in some circles as a future right-handed Babe Ruth. Tony C came every bit as advertised and were it not for his tragic beaning in 1967, he might be in the Hall of Fame.

On the other hand, there are a ton of pitchers who got the star treatment while they were in fourth grade, or so it would seem. One was Craig Hansen, the 2006 phenom. The Red Sox were so high on him that they rushed him to the majors and completely ruined him. They’ve done that a lot.

It remains to be seen whether Anthony can withstand the curse of high expectations. (Thanks, Ken Brett.) The Red Sox have done due diligence, even trotting out David Ortiz to praise him to the heavens. Anthony has established himself as a player to watch during the World Baseball Classic, but let’s keep the Hall of Fame plaque on hold for now. Let him go through an entire season, with the usual dips and surges, before beginning to pass judgement.

It would be a crime if Anthony ends up in the dustbin of Red Sox phenoms.

  • Steve Krause

    Steve Krause is the Item’s writer-at-large. He joined paper in 1979 as a copy editor and later created a music column, called Midnight Ramblings, which ran through 1985. After leaving the paper for a year, he returned in 1988 as a reporter and editor in sports. He became sports editor in 1998; and was named writer-at-large in 2018.

    Krause won awards for writing in 1985 from United Press International; in 2001 from the Associated Press; and again in 2020 from the New England Newspaper & Press Association. He is a member of the Harry Agganis Foundation Hall of Fame, a past winner of the Moynihan Lumber Scholar-Athlete Community Service Award, and was the 2012 recipient of the Jack Grinold Media Award for MasterSports, an organization that conducts high school and college coaches’ clinics. He lives in Lynn, is active on Facebook, and can be found on Twitter @itemkrause.



    View all posts






Source link

24World Media does not take any responsibility of the information you see on this page. The content this page contains is from independent third-party content provider. If you have any concerns regarding the content, please free to write us here: contact@24worldmedia.com

Latest Post

Saugus man sentenced to 19 years for drug trafficking

Last Updated,Mar 18, 2026

Northshore Mall announces first North Shore locations of Fogo de Chão and Shake Shack

Last Updated,Mar 18, 2026

EDIC’s Cowdell calls it a career

Last Updated,Mar 18, 2026

Editorial: With AI demand surging, Texas can’t stand in the way of renewables

Last Updated,Mar 18, 2026

Commentary: The trillion dollar Iran war

Last Updated,Mar 18, 2026

Commentary: Trump’s ‘just for fun’ war talk shows a dangerous trivialization

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026

Saugus staple goes for gelato

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026

60 years later, a Lynn hero is honored

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026

Two-sport captain Tessa Andriano ready for one last swing

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026

North Fork high schools named to 2025 AP Honor Roll

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026

Krause: Don’t light off the Roman candle just yet

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026

Athlete of the Week – Bishop Fenwick’s Celia Neilson

Last Updated,Mar 17, 2026